The reply, actually from White House Pardon Attorney, Ronald Rodgers says:
"It is the general policy of the Department of Justice that requests for posthumous pardons for federal offences not be processed for adjudication. The policy is grounded in the belief that the time of the officials involved in the clemency process is better spent on pardon and commutation requests of living persons.Now, there are doubts as to whether or not President Obama has ever actually seen a request for the pardon. Parker says, "I think if President Obama reads it, he will sign it." Similarly, the Head of the Marcus Garvey-founded People's Political Party, says, "The language used in the reply is most disdainful. It makes you wonder if Obama actually read the request. Obama must know about Garvey, who is the forerunner of the civil rights movement. It is most disappointing." See story here.
"Many posthumous pardon requests would likely be based on a claim of manifest injustice, and given that decades have passed since the event and the historical record would have to be scoured to objectively and comprehensively investigate such applications, it is the Department's position that the limited resources which are available to process requests for Presidential clemency -- now being submitted in record numbers -- are best dedicated to requests submitted by persons who can truly benefit from a grant of the request,"
While we agree with the general policy expressed by the Pardon Attorney (for a variety of reasons), we cannot help but also add that, should the President find the lure of hollow, symbolic pardoning irresistible (as did Bill Clinton and George W. Bush), then, in our view, Marcus Garvey is a much, much more deserving recipient than Jack Johnson.