It is reported that President Obama will be granting clemency in a hundred or so cases some time in the next few days. Here is how his administration compares to previous administrations re December pardons:
|Click on Image (Above) to Enlarge|
First, December pardoning sends the signal that the pardon power is an afterthought, something to consider - maybe - just before the year closes out. This impression certainly seems to fit the Obama administration, which has done precious little pardoning for seven years. It is also easy enough to imagine such decision making as rushed, indefensibly casual and/or lacking the kind of careful deliberation that is warranted. Justice, however, should be a year-round, serious concern of a president (and a Department of Justice in an executive branch) constitutionally lodged in a system of checks and balances. If there is no checking, there will be no balance.
Second, December pardoning signals the possibility of a kind of alternate scenario: that clemency decisions are, actually, made throughout the year, but the White House simply sits on applications until December ... for whatever reason. So, the President decides someone deserves a pardon or commutation of sentence, in January, but nothing is actually done for 11 months. They just sit in prison for another 11 months. Or they live without restoration of their civil rights for another 11 months. That is more than lazy, or irresponsible. It is a despicable practice. See a previous post here.
Third, December pardoning suggests to the general public that pardons are something like "gifts" given to persons who may or may not actually deserve them. That is too bad, because we have no problem assuming most recipients of clemency in this day and age are more than deserving. Why should a cloud of suspicion / disrespect be cast over them? Of course, the "gift" idea is exacerbated by long periods of time without pardoning. Observers more easily wonder - and rightly - "why these people?"
For seven years, the Obama administration has been one of the most merciless in American history, slow to pardon, stingy in grants and comfortable to do absolutely nothing for months at a time.
Here's to a New Year's Resolution for 2016: Do it differently, Mr. President, radically!